Tenon boss defends pre-packs following sale of Bridge Communications

Insolvency practitioner Tenon has defended pre-pack deals, claiming they can reduce the "domino effect" on suppliers.

The comments come as suppliers to the print industry have criticised new guidelines aimed at increasing transparency in pre-pack administrations, saying that they do not go far enough towards ensuring best value for creditors.

Carl Jackson, national head of the London-based administrator, said the deals are an essential part of "an insolvency firm's toolkit".

He added: "The administrator is duty-bound to act on behalf of creditors to maximise any potential return and they will only agree to a pre-pack if it ticks that box."

Comparing the benefits over a standard administration sale, Jackson said pre-packs can maximise the returns to the secured creditor, reduce the levels of creditor claims and allow a creditor access to future profit at the failed business.

According to Jackson, pre-packs can sometimes prevent further insolvencies of suppliers or creditors through the continuity of supply, as well as preserving the jobs of employees.

He added: "Allowing a business to continue can help to reduce the domino effect we saw with Rover Cars, when a large number of suppliers failed as a result.  

"We saw this, more recently in December when Woolworths' demise contributed to Zavvi's failure at the start of year.  

"Ultimately, it is important to recognise that pre-pack insolvencies are a key option in an insolvency practitioner's toolkit."

His comments came as Bridge Communications, the Essex-based direct mail specialist was sold by Tenon in a pre-pack to Euro Media Solutions, which is headed up by Paul White, on 29 December – the same day that it went into administration.


Pre-pack benefits:

  • Prevention of further insolvencies
  • decrease in redundancies
  • maximum return to the secured creditor
  • reduced level of creditor claims
  • future profit participation
  • suppliers can increase pricing